Familywise Error Rate Control via Knockoffs
نویسندگان
چکیده
We present a novel method for controlling the k-familywise error rate (k-FWER) in the linear regression setting using the knockoffs framework first introduced by Barber and Candès. Our procedure, which we also refer to as knockoffs, can be applied with any design matrix with at least as many observations as variables, and does not require knowing the noise variance. Unlike other multiple testing procedures which act directly on p-values, knockoffs is specifically tailored to linear regression and implicitly accounts for the statistical relationships between hypothesis tests of different coefficients. We prove that knockoffs controls the k-FWER exactly in finite samples and show in simulations that it provides superior power to alternative procedures over a range of linear regression problems. We also discuss extensions to controlling other Type I error rates such as the false exceedance rate, and use it to identify candidates for mutations conferring drug-resistance in HIV.
منابع مشابه
Familywise Error Rate Control via Knockoffs
We present a novel method for controlling the k-familywise error rate (k-FWER) in the linear regression setting using the knockoffs framework first introduced by Barber and Candès. Our procedure, which we also refer to as knockoffs, can be applied with any design matrix with at least as many observations as variables, and does not require knowing the noise variance. Unlike other multiple testin...
متن کاملPer Family or Familywise Type I Error Control: "Eether, Eyether, Neether, Nyther, Let's Call the Whole Thing Off!"
Frane (2015) pointed out the difference between per-family and familywise Type I error control and how different multiple comparison procedures control one method but not necessarily the other. He then went on to demonstrate in the context of a two group multivariate design containing different numbers of dependent variables and correlations between variables how the per-family rate inflates be...
متن کاملA note on adaptive Bonferroni and Holm procedures under dependence
Hochberg & Benjamini (1990) first presented adaptive procedures for controlling familywise error rate. However, until now, it has not been proved that these procedures control the familywise error rate. We introduce a simplified version of Hochberg & Benjamini’s adaptive Bonferroni and Holm procedures. Assuming a conditional dependence model, we prove that the former procedure controls the fami...
متن کاملGENE HUNTING WITH KNOCKOFFS FOR HIDDEN MARKOV MODELS By
Modern scientific studies often require the identification of a subset of relevant explanatory variables, in the attempt to understand an interesting phenomenon. Several statistical methods have been developed to automate this task, but only recently has the framework of model-free knockoffs proposed a general solution that can perform variable selection under rigorous type-I error control, wit...
متن کاملON STEPWISE CONTROL OF DIRECTIONAL ERRORS UNDER INDEPENDENCE AND SOME DEPENDENCE By
In this paper, the problem of error control of stepwise multiple testing procedures is considered. For two-sided hypotheses, control of both type 1 and type 3 (or directional) errors is required, and thus mixed directional familywise error rate control and mixed directional false discovery rate control are each considered by incorporating both types of errors in the error rate. Mixed directiona...
متن کامل